Olcott Beach, NY · since the good old days
A scoop of summer
Hand-spun ice cream on the south shore of Lake Ontario. Come for the cones, stay for the sunset.
See our menuAbout the shop
Made in Olcott. Made for summer.
Our flavors rotate with the season — strawberries when the local fields come in, peach when the orchards are picking, and lake-effect vanilla all summer long. Come early, come often, and don't be shy about trying something new.
More than a cone
There's always something going on
You never know who'll turn up — Woody from the toy store has been known to stroll by, and there are free balloons for the kids whenever the mood strikes. Inside, the player piano keeps the place humming all summer long.
Meet the crew
Highly trained scoop masters
Every cone is built by a highly trained scoop master — graduates of the Mystic Ice Cream Boot Camp, holders of an advanced degree in gelato from Pregel University, and proud members of the North American Ice Cream Association. We take our scooping seriously (and not seriously at all).
“If summer had a flavor, it'd taste like a Goody's cone on the pier.”
— Niagara County local
Catering & group orders
Birthdays, weddings, lake-house get-togethers — we'll bring the cones. Reach out a few days in advance and we'll take care of the rest.
We also sponsor milkshake giveaways at local golf tournaments — ask us about bringing Goody's to your event.