Goodys at the Beach
  • Menu Items
  • Events
  • Specials
  • From the Window
  • Our Story
  • Visit

Menu Items

Hand-spun in small batches every day with upstate dairy and local fruit in season. Pick your item, pick your size.

Pricing: Kayak $6 · Canoe $7.25

Drinks ($3.50 / $5): Goody's Lemonade · Bell's Sweet Iced Tea

Got a catch, a soup, a pie, or a batch of cookies? We'll trade you ice cream for it.

  • Milkshakes

    Milkshakes

    Hand-spun thick, topped with whipped cream

  • Water & Soda

    Ice-cold, always on hand

  • Fresh-Squeezed Lemonade

    Squeezed to order, never a mix

  • Popsicles, Creamsicles & Paletas

    Frozen treats for the pier

  • House-Made Waffle Cookies

    We bake our own

  • Bye's Caramel Corn Ice Cream

    Bye's Caramel Corn Ice Cream

    Salty-sweet and crunchy

  • Hot Fudge Sundae & Pints

    Sundaes and hand-packed pints

  • Gelato

    Italian-style, from the Pregel grads

  • Salty Caramel Dream

    La Lechera marries Ghirardelli

  • PB and J

    An American classic!

  • Coffee Craving

    Have this with your breakfast

  • Butter Candy Pecan

    Comes with a Georgia accent

  • Weekly Special Treat

    This will surprise you every time! Ask at the counter.

  • Maple Tree Walnut

    Yes we have to rake the leaves

  • Oreo Wonder

    Who invented this cookie?

  • Mint Pop

    A peppermint twist!

  • Chocolate Silk

    You could like this on toast!

  • Vanilla Honey

    The Apiary is down the road

Goody's at the Beach

A seasonal family ice cream shop on the south shore of Lake Ontario. Come find us by the carousel.

5985 E Main St, Olcott Beach, NY 14028

(716) 555-0123

hello@goodysolcott.com

Hours

Friday: 12:00pm – 9:00pm

Saturday: 12:00pm – 9:00pm

Sunday: 12:00pm – 9:00pm

Also open Memorial Day, the 4th of July, and Labor Day.

  • Instagram
  • Facebook
  • Google